CASE 03 · ST AGNES ISLAND, CORNWALL · 1952 · EVIDENCE GUIDE

Evidence and weapons in The Saltwater Alibi

At 9:40 PM the St Agnes light goes dark. When the reserve lamp returns, keeper Elias Ward is dead and the rising tide has trapped four suspects on the island.

The Saltwater Alibi holds six clues and five possible weapons. This guide describes each object and its history without revealing which one killed, because that changes across the case’s five solutions.

Play this case · Read the case file for The Saltwater Alibi

FIVE POSSIBLE WEAPONS

Only one was used

Every weapon below has an ordinary history in the case. Which one became the murder weapon changes with each of the five solutions.

WEAPON 01 · FIRST FOUND IN LANTERN ROOM

Brass signal lamp

The heavy lamp has a new dent and salt-wet wool caught beneath its handle.

Tom Hesk’s reserve equipment includes portable lamps for gallery checks. Handling a lamp is part of both keeper and visitor safety routines.

WEAPON 02 · FIRST FOUND IN KEEPER’S COTTAGE

Morphine ampoule

One numbered ampoule and its period syringe are missing from a doctor’s case.

Beatrice Shaw brings a numbered medical case on island calls. Alice Penrose’s child explains legitimate treatment activity, not the contents of Elias’s examination.

WEAPON 03 · FIRST FOUND IN BOATHOUSE

Sailor’s marlinspike

The steel spike carries fresh blue paint from the boathouse workbench.

Callum Reed and Billy Curnow use rope tools at the blue-painted workbench; working paint must be distinguished from a fresh contact trace.

WEAPON 04 · FIRST FOUND IN ISLAND CHAPEL

Chapel candlestick

Blood remains beneath the dried wax around its dented brass base.

Edmund Rowe moves chapel brass when arranging relief boxes for Nora Pike. Wax may cover an older mark, so its layers matter.

WEAPON 05 · FIRST FOUND IN TIDAL CAVE

Weighted diving line

The shortened line and lead sinker carry fibers and pale cave limestone.

Gideon Vale’s survey and local salvage work use weighted lines. Inventory length can separate an ordinary coil from the particular shortened braid.

SIX CLUES TO RECOVER

One clue in every location

Solve each room’s visual puzzle to recover its clue. What the clue proves depends on the playthrough.

  • A tide entry written twice — lantern room
  • A cracked cup and ampoule — keeper’s cottage
  • A cut rope beneath an oilskin — boathouse
  • A torn relief register — island chapel
  • Bootprints and a pearl button — tidal cave
  • A severed transmission wire — radio room

HIDDEN KEEPSAKE

A collectible for careful eyes

Each case hides one optional keepsake for your detective dossier.

COLLECTIBLE

St Agnes storm glass

A piece of cobalt sea glass wrapped in a keeper’s brass wire, polished by decades of winter tides.

Evidence in other Motive cases