ST AGNES ISLAND, CORNWALL · 1952 · ONLINE MURDER MYSTERY

The Saltwater Alibi

At 9:40 PM the St Agnes light goes dark. When the reserve lamp returns, keeper Elias Ward is dead and the rising tide has trapped four suspects on the island.

Play this case

Read the truth in the tide

The Saltwater Alibi is a coastal murder mystery set on an isolated Cornish island in 1952. Trace the keeper’s last movements across the lighthouse, cottage, boathouse, chapel, sea cave, and radio hut while a gale erases the obvious routes.

The island’s timetable is written in tides, signal logs, rope, medicine, and wet footprints. Each of five solution variations rearranges the decisive evidence, giving solo players and detective parties a fresh but fully reasoned case.

What you will investigate

Cross a storm-sealed island

Discover six atmospheric locations connected by paths, old duties, and a causeway already under water.

Decode maritime evidence

Examine lighthouse records, radio wiring, medicine, rope, and traces the weather has not yet destroyed.

Break a watertight alibi

Test four islanders’ stories against the tide and submit one complete theory before your chances run out.

Case facts

Setting
St Agnes Lighthouse, St Agnes Island, Cornwall
Date of the crime
November 3, 1952
Playing time
90–120 min
Players
1–5, solo or in a detective party
Locations
6 searchable locations
Suspects
4 persons of interest
Solutions
5 complete variations
Access
Premium · optional unlock

Explore the case file

Frequently asked questions

How long does The Saltwater Alibi take to solve?

Most detectives need 90 to 120 minutes to search all 6 locations, recover the evidence, and submit a complete theory. Progress is saved, so you can return to the case later.

Can I play The Saltwater Alibi with friends?

Yes. The Saltwater Alibi is designed for 1–5 players. Investigate alone, or invite friends to a detective party and share clues, notes, and theories as you play.

Who are the suspects in The Saltwater Alibi?

The persons of interest are Beatrice Shaw (island doctor), Callum Reed (fisherman), Nora Pike (hotel proprietor), and Gideon Vale (naval surveyor). Each has a motive and an alibi the evidence must test.

Is the solution to The Saltwater Alibi the same every time?

No. Each investigation selects one of 5 complete solutions, changing the culprit, location, weapon, and supporting evidence together. Replaying the case means reasoning through a new trail.

How do I access The Saltwater Alibi?

The Saltwater Alibi is an optional Premium case. Unlock it once from the Motive case archive to keep it in your library.

Explore more Motive cases