CASE 01 · ASHCOMBE, ENGLAND · 1927 · EVIDENCE GUIDE

Evidence and weapons in The Blackthorn Affair

A country-house toast ends in darkness. When the lamps return, Alistair Blackthorn is dead in his library and everyone under his roof has a reason to lie.

The Blackthorn Affair holds six clues and five possible weapons. This guide describes each object and its history without revealing which one killed, because that changes across the case’s five solutions.

Play this case · Read the case file for The Blackthorn Affair

FIVE POSSIBLE WEAPONS

Only one was used

Every weapon below has an ordinary history in the case. Which one became the murder weapon changes with each of the five solutions.

WEAPON 01 · FIRST FOUND IN DINING ROOM

Poisoned teacup

A single cup from the dinner service carries an unexplained residue.

Henry Tull’s service notes distinguish Alistair’s private cup from cups used by Evelyn Blackthorn and the visiting advisers.

WEAPON 02 · FIRST FOUND IN LIBRARY

Brass letter opener

An ornate desk blade bears wax fragments and a snagged green fiber.

Arthur Hale uses the desk blade for sealed estate papers. Its ordinary presence among family correspondence gives several guests a reason to handle it.

WEAPON 03 · FIRST FOUND IN DINING ROOM

Digitalis vial

An amber apothecary bottle was recovered beside an overturned glass.

Ashcombe pharmacy issues numbered wrappers separately from the manor’s pantry supplies. A household shelf does not establish the original purchaser.

WEAPON 04 · FIRST FOUND IN DINING ROOM

Cyanide serving spoon

A serving spoon was separated from the tea service after being wiped.

Mara Finch and Rose Fenwick return serving silver by tray number; serving, clearing, and later cleaning are separate opportunities for contact.

WEAPON 05 · FIRST FOUND IN STUDY

Bronze cipher wheel

The heavy study cipher has a fresh dent and traces of brass dust.

Julian Cross’s export correspondence uses the Study cipher. Arthur Hale also consults those cables when drafting the mill contracts.

SIX CLUES TO RECOVER

One clue in every location

Solve each room’s visual puzzle to recover its clue. What the clue proves depends on the playthrough.

  • A torn ledger page — library
  • A stopped pocket watch — ballroom
  • A place set for seven — dining room
  • A coded telegram — study
  • A bitter trace — kitchen
  • Moonlit footprints — conservatory

HIDDEN KEEPSAKE

A collectible for careful eyes

Each case hides one optional keepsake for your detective dossier.

COLLECTIBLE

The Blackthorn raven seal

A tiny onyx seal engraved with the family raven. It was never entered into the official evidence ledger.

Evidence in other Motive cases