CASE 03 · ST AGNES ISLAND, CORNWALL · 1952 · LOCATIONS GUIDE

The locations of The Saltwater Alibi

At 9:40 PM the St Agnes light goes dark. When the reserve lamp returns, keeper Elias Ward is dead and the rising tide has trapped four suspects on the island.

The Saltwater Alibi is investigated across six locations. This guide describes each place, the clue waiting there, and the people with an ordinary reason to pass through it—without revealing where the murder happened.

Play this case · Read the case file for The Saltwater Alibi

SIX-LOCATION CASE MAP

Search St Agnes Lighthouse

Search six isolated locations and determine what happened before the causeway vanished.

LOCATION 01

Lantern Room

Tom Hesk maintains the reserve light separately from Elias’s log. Gideon Vale’s reef survey depends on soundings beyond the causeway, while Callum Reed reads the beacon from his boat. A change in the light can affect both men without dating a private encounter.

Evidence to recover
A tide entry written twice
Possible weapon found here
Brass signal lamp

LOCATION 02

Keeper’s Cottage

Alice Penrose brought her injured child to Beatrice Shaw during the gale; the emergency card belongs to that visit. Elias’s older medical correspondence concerns Beatrice’s husband’s inquest. Distinguish that historical dispute from the treatment record, and establish the visit’s timing from the active observations.

Evidence to recover
A cracked cup and ampoule
Possible weapon found here
Morphine ampoule

LOCATION 03

Boathouse

Billy Curnow keeps the net tally while Callum Reed handles deliveries for Nora Pike. Gideon Vale also stores survey gear here. The marlinspike, lamp gear, and spare waders have ordinary jobs; a fresh workbench trace must establish which object mattered to Elias’s last visit.

Evidence to recover
A cut rope beneath an oilskin
Possible weapon found here
Sailor’s marlinspike

LOCATION 04

Island Chapel

Edmund Rowe checks storm-relief stock against Nora Pike’s accounts. Callum Reed’s delivery quantities and Elias’s retained totals can be compared here. Candles, a vestry cart, and the register belong to routine relief work; their condition tonight must be established independently.

Evidence to recover
A torn relief register
Possible weapon found here
Chapel candlestick

LOCATION 05

Tidal Cave

The dry ledge overlooks the wreck ground on Gideon Vale’s salvage chart. Elias retained a strongbox inventory from the war; Callum Reed knows the water below the lift point. A falling tide can expose old material while storm surge still prevents a mainland crossing.

Evidence to recover
Bootprints and a pearl button
Possible weapon found here
Weighted diving line

LOCATION 06

Radio Room

June Ellis handles receiver tests and outgoing mainland calls. Elias’s intended reports concern reef depths, relief money, and offshore traffic; Gideon Vale helps with aerial checks. Identify the message and its independent receipt before assuming every cut line concealed the same dispute.

Evidence to recover
A severed transmission wire

Locations in other Motive cases