CASE 01 · ASHCOMBE, ENGLAND · 1927 · SUSPECTS GUIDE

The suspects in The Blackthorn Affair

A country-house toast ends in darkness. When the lamps return, Alistair Blackthorn is dead in his library and everyone under his roof has a reason to lie.

This spoiler-free guide collects what the case file for The Blackthorn Affair establishes before your first clue. It never names the culprit: each investigation selects one of five solutions, so the person lying can change between playthroughs.

Play this case · Read the case file for The Blackthorn Affair

PERSONS OF INTEREST

Four suspects, four stories

Each suspect had access, a reason to fear the victim, and an account of the evening that the evidence must test.

SUSPECT 01 · THE ELDEST DAUGHTER

Evelyn Blackthorn

Alistair’s eldest child and the presumed heir to Blackthorn Manor. Evelyn wants the east lodge converted into a school rather than sold. Arthur Hale handles its trust papers; Mara Finch knows how long Evelyn has argued with her father over the lodge keys.

Motive
Her inheritance, independence, and place in the family all depended on documents her father could change overnight.
Stated alibi
Claims she took a sleeping draught and retired to the east guest room before 11:30.
My father enjoyed making us afraid of what he might take away. That is not the same as wishing him dead.

SUSPECT 02 · THE FAMILY SOLICITOR

Arthur Hale

The Blackthorn family solicitor for nineteen years and trustee of the estate. Arthur’s Ashcombe chambers hold both family deeds and mill contracts. Julian Cross negotiates the commercial terms, while Evelyn Blackthorn must ask Arthur for copies of documents bearing her own name.

Motive
He controlled accounts, contracts, and trusts that Alistair had recently ordered an outside auditor to examine.
Stated alibi
Says he was alone in the study on a telephone call when the lights failed.
I protected this family from its own appetites. Alistair knew the cost of that better than anyone.

SUSPECT 03 · THE HOUSEKEEPER

Mara Finch

Housekeeper of Blackthorn Manor, with access to every room and every household key. Her son Daniel Finch worked in the mill warehouse. Mara has asked Julian Cross for his wage book and Arthur Hale for a hearing; neither request has resolved Alistair’s accusation.

Motive
Alistair held evidence against her son and had prepared changes to the household staff.
Stated alibi
Claims she was completing the pantry inventory with the kitchen maid until the blackout.
A house keeps its master’s secrets long after it stops respecting him.

SUSPECT 04 · THE BUSINESS PARTNER

Julian Cross

Alistair’s business partner and the public face of Blackthorn Industries. Julian brokered the mill’s export orders through Harbury docks. Mara Finch’s son handled warehouse dispatches, and Arthur Hale drafted the agreements now awaiting Florence Mercer’s review.

Motive
A broken partnership could expose missing company money and confidential dealings with a rival.
Stated alibi
Insists he left for the station before dessert and did not return to the manor.
Alistair made enemies for sport. You are wasting time looking only at the dinner table.

WITNESSES & STAFF

People who keep the record

These people are not suspects. Their registers, logs, and recollections help confirm or break an alibi at Blackthorn Manor.

  • Rose Fenwick — kitchen maid
  • Henry Tull — dining steward
  • Agnes Lowe — estate accounts clerk
  • Edwin Price — ballroom pianist
  • Walter Briggs — footman
  • Mabel Stone — telephone exchange operator

Suspects in other Motive cases