CASE 11 · PARIS, FRANCE · 1922 · SUSPECTS GUIDE
The suspects in The Velvet Auction
Lot Seventeen goes under the hammer at Maison Vesper. Before the winning bid is announced, auctioneer Étienne Vesper is found dead and the painting’s provenance has vanished.
This spoiler-free guide collects what the case file for The Velvet Auction establishes before your first clue. It never names the culprit: each investigation selects one of five solutions, so the person lying can change between playthroughs.
Play this case · Read the case file for The Velvet AuctionPERSONS OF INTEREST
Four suspects, four stories
Each suspect had access, a reason to fear the victim, and an account of the evening that the evidence must test.
SUSPECT 01 · PAINTING RESTORER
Odette Fournier
Restored the disputed painting for Étienne. Odette has shared pigment results with Mei Laurent but Étienne wants an unqualified certificate. Henri Beaumont’s ownership claim depends on the sale looking authentic to bidders who never enter her studio.
- Motive
- Étienne intended to certify a forgery and blame her when it failed inspection.
- Stated alibi
- Says she stayed in the studio cleaning brushes.
Varnish can hide a history. It cannot give a new painting an old one.
SUSPECT 02 · AUCTION CLERK
Luc Morel
Recorded bids and private deposits. Luc registers Henri Beaumont’s deposits and pays Mei Laurent’s research fees. Étienne controls the ledger, while Claire Dubois expects Luc’s paddle numbers to agree with the bidders actually present.
- Motive
- Étienne had discovered that he redirected unclaimed deposits.
- Stated alibi
- Says he was checking paddle numbers in the salon.
Some bids are made with a raised hand. The expensive ones happen behind closed doors.
SUSPECT 03 · PRIVATE COLLECTOR
Henri Beaumont
Claimed his family once owned Lot Seventeen. Henri claims a family connection to Lot Seventeen. Mei Laurent wants the earlier ownership papers, and Odette Fournier’s tests could reduce the painting’s value before Luc Morel accepts his bid.
- Motive
- Étienne possessed evidence that his collection included stolen works.
- Stated alibi
- Says he watched the gallery from the salon doorway.
That painting was mine before Vesper invented a paper trail for it.
SUSPECT 04 · PROVENANCE SCHOLAR
Mei Laurent
Was hired to authenticate the painting’s ownership record. Mei has followed Lot Seventeen through old collection records and compared her findings with Odette Fournier. Étienne controls her credit, while Henri Beaumont disputes the history she intends to publish.
- Motive
- Étienne was publishing her research under another name and suppressing its conclusion.
- Stated alibi
- Says she was examining crate seals in the packing room.
I followed the paper to its source. Vesper asked me to stop one page too soon.
WITNESSES & STAFF
People who keep the record
These people are not suspects. Their registers, logs, and recollections help confirm or break an alibi at Maison Vesper.
- Jules Perrin — packing porter
- Claire Dubois — salon attendant
- René Vidal — accounts cashier
- Alice Martin — studio assistant
Suspects in other Motive cases
- The suspects in The Blackthorn Affair
- The suspects in Death on the Meridian
- The suspects in The Saltwater Alibi
- The suspects in Last Curtain at Belladonna
- The suspects in Signal at Hollow Peak
- The suspects in The Glasshouse Requiem
- The suspects in The Clockwork Testament
- The suspects in The Sirocco Cipher
- The suspects in The Nightjar Transmission
- The suspects in Murder at the Marigold
- The suspects in The Obsidian Crossing