CASE 05 · HOLLOW PEAK, SCOTLAND · 1963 · SUSPECTS GUIDE
The suspects in Signal at Hollow Peak
An impossible signal reaches a snowbound radio observatory. Seven minutes later Dr Ada Mercer is dead, the record is erased, and the mountain road has disappeared beneath the snow.
This spoiler-free guide collects what the case file for Signal at Hollow Peak establishes before your first clue. It never names the culprit: each investigation selects one of five solutions, so the person lying can change between playthroughs.
Play this case · Read the case file for Signal at Hollow PeakPERSONS OF INTEREST
Four suspects, four stories
Each suspect had access, a reason to fear the victim, and an account of the evening that the evidence must test.
SUSPECT 01 · THE DEPUTY ASTRONOMER
Dr Rowan Keir
Ada Mercer’s deputy, collaborator, and expected successor at Hollow Peak. Rowan needs Iris Bell’s foundation to accept his discovery credit. Malcolm Pike maintains the calibration system, and Celia North’s broadcast could settle the public story before Ada’s objections reach Edinburgh.
- Motive
- Ada had challenged his claim to the mysterious signal and prepared to remove his name from the discovery.
- Stated alibi
- Claims he watched the dish tracking motors alone on the exposed platform throughout the aurora.
The sky does not care who receives the signal first. Institutions care very much.
SUSPECT 02 · THE SCIENCE CORRESPONDENT
Celia North
A national broadcaster invited to record Ada’s announcement from the summit. Celia has promised a summit exclusive to her editor. Rowan Keir supplies scientific explanations, but Ada’s retained interview and Iris Bell’s restrictions on publication complicate what she can safely broadcast.
- Motive
- Ada had found that Celia’s most famous reporting relied on stolen and classified research.
- Stated alibi
- Says she remained in the summit quarters editing their taped interview.
Ada understood that a discovery without a witness is only a rumour.
SUSPECT 03 · THE CHIEF ENGINEER
Malcolm Pike
Builder and keeper of Hollow Peak’s electrical, mechanical, and radio systems. Malcolm orders the components funded by Iris Bell and installed for Rowan Keir. Ada’s invoice review connects workshop purchases to a research budget that outsiders rarely see.
- Motive
- Missing components and duplicate invoices could end his career and expose a profitable scheme.
- Stated alibi
- Insists he was restarting the lower generator after the control-room lights flickered.
Every instrument up here lies eventually. People simply learn faster.
SUSPECT 04 · THE FOUNDATION TRUSTEE
Iris Bell
Chair of the foundation that financed Hollow Peak and controlled its patents. Iris answers to Edinburgh trustees while managing private patent interests. Rowan Keir wants recognition and Malcolm Pike needs equipment; Ada’s proposed open report threatens the compromises behind both requests.
- Motive
- Ada intended to reveal that public research had been redirected into companies Iris secretly owned.
- Stated alibi
- Claims she waited in the archive for a secure telephone line to Edinburgh.
Discovery is expensive. Someone always mistakes the invoice for a crime.
WITNESSES & STAFF
People who keep the record
These people are not suspects. Their registers, logs, and recollections help confirm or break an alibi at Hollow Peak Observatory.
- Moira Grant — darkroom assistant
- Douglas Kerr — reserve technician
- Jean McLeod — archive clerk
- Alan Ross — duty observer
Suspects in other Motive cases
- The suspects in The Blackthorn Affair
- The suspects in Death on the Meridian
- The suspects in The Saltwater Alibi
- The suspects in Last Curtain at Belladonna
- The suspects in The Glasshouse Requiem
- The suspects in The Clockwork Testament
- The suspects in The Sirocco Cipher
- The suspects in The Nightjar Transmission
- The suspects in Murder at the Marigold
- The suspects in The Velvet Auction
- The suspects in The Obsidian Crossing